How Gradient calculation in batch size.

 Let's use a simplified example with just 2 data points and walk through the process with actual numbers. This will help illustrate how gradients are calculated and accumulated for a batch.

Let's assume we have a very simple model with one parameter w, currently set to 1.0. Our loss function is the square error, and we're using basic gradient descent with a learning rate of 0.1.

Data points:

  1. x1 = 2, y1 = 4
  2. x2 = 3, y2 = 5

Batch size = 2 (both data points in one batch)

Step 1: Forward pass

  • For x1: prediction = w * x1 = 1.0 * 2 = 2
  • For x2: prediction = w * x2 = 1.0 * 3 = 3

Step 2: Calculate losses

  • Loss1 = (prediction1 - y1)^2 = (2 - 4)^2 = 4
  • Loss2 = (prediction2 - y2)^2 = (3 - 5)^2 = 4
  • Total batch loss = (Loss1 + Loss2) / 2 = (4 + 4) / 2 = 4

Step 3: Backward pass (calculate gradients)

  • Gradient1 = 2 * (prediction1 - y1) * x1 = 2 * (2 - 4) * 2 = -8
  • Gradient2 = 2 * (prediction2 - y2) * x2 = 2 * (3 - 5) * 3 = -12

Step 4: Accumulate gradients

  • Total gradient = (Gradient1 + Gradient2) / 2 = (-8 + -12) / 2 = -10

Step 5: Update weight (once for the batch)

  • New w = old w - learning_rate * total gradient
  • New w = 1.0 - 0.1 * (-10) = 2.0

So, after processing this batch of 2 data points:

  • We calculated 2 individual gradients (-8 and -12)
  • We accumulated these into one total gradient (-10)
  • We performed one weight update, changing w from 1.0 to 2.0

This process would then repeat for the next batch. In this case, we've processed all our data, so this completes one epoch.

How many GPUs do I need to train a LLM?



How many GPUs do I need to train a LLM?

This is a complicated question in general, but if we assume that you are using FSDP with 
FULL_SHARD, activation checkpointing, and DecoupledLionW, then a good rule of thumb is:

Your total cluster memory in GB should be larger than 12 * N (# billions of params).

E.g. To train a GPT-13B model which has ~13 billion params, 
have at least 12 * 13 = 156 GB of total memory across your GPUs. 
You can accomplish this with 4xA100-40GB, or 2xA100-80GB, etc.

If you run into OOM errors when using small device counts, 
reduce device_train_microbatch_size until it succeeds.

Keep in mind: even though training will work in these minimalist settings, 
you will get much better throughput_per_device 
if you use a larger cluster or devices with higher memory capacity, 
because this will enable you to use larger microbatch sizes.

What is TorchOps.cpp.inc in torch-mlir

 

What is TorchOps.cpp.inc?

  • TorchOps.cpp.inc: This file contains implementations of the operations for the torch-mlir dialect. It is typically generated from .td (TableGen) files that define the dialect and its operations.
  • The .td (TableGen) files describe MLIR operations in a high-level, declarative form, and the cmake build process automatically generates .cpp.inc files (like TorchOps.cpp.inc) from these .td files.

How it gets generated:

  1. TableGen: The TableGen tool processes .td files that define the operations and attributes for the torch dialect.
  2. CMake Build: During the CMake build process, the mlir-tblgen tool is invoked to generate various .inc files, including TorchOps.cpp.inc.

Where It Is Generated:

The TorchOps.cpp.inc file is usually generated in the build directory under the subdirectories for the torch-mlir project. For example:


build/tools/torch-mlir/lib/Dialect/Torch/IR/TorchOps.cpp.inc

This file gets included in the compiled source code to provide the implementation of the Torch dialect operations.

How to Ensure It Is Generated:

If the file is missing, it's likely because there was an issue in the build process. Here’s how to ensure it’s generated:

  1. Ensure CMake and Ninja Build: Make sure the CMake and Ninja build process is working correctly by following the steps we discussed earlier. You can check that the TorchOps.cpp.inc file is generated by looking in the build directory:

    ls build/tools/torch-mlir/lib/Dialect/Torch/IR/
  2. Check for TableGen Files: Make sure that the .td files (such as TorchOps.td) are present in the source directory. These are used by mlir-tblgen to generate the .cpp.inc files.

Debugging if Not Generated:

If TorchOps.cpp.inc or similar files are not generated, ensure:

  • You are running the full build using ninja or make.
  • mlir-tblgen is being invoked during the build process (you should see log messages referencing mlir-tblgen).